There’s a number that most prop firm CEOs never look at.
It’s not CAC. It’s not ROAS. It’s not even revenue.
It’s repeat purchase rate.
What percentage of traders who buy a challenge come back and buy another one?
If you don’t know that number off the top of your head, you have a problem.
Because for most prop firms, the answer is embarrassingly low. Not because the traders don’t want to come back. But because nobody asked them to.
Think about what happens when a trader fails a challenge at most firms. They get a generic email saying their evaluation period ended. Maybe a discount code. Maybe nothing at all.
And then silence.
That trader already knows your product. They already navigated your checkout. They already trusted you enough to spend money once. They are the easiest person in the world to sell to again.
And you ghosted them.
The Math That Should Keep You Up at Night
Let’s run the numbers.
Acquiring a new trader through paid ads costs somewhere between $15 and $50 depending on your platform, geo, and offer. Some firms are paying $80 or more in competitive markets.
Getting a previous buyer to purchase again costs almost nothing. An email. Maybe a retargeting ad at pennies on the dollar.
Acquisition vs Retention Cost Comparison
If your repeat purchase rate is 10% and you could move it to 25%, you just increased revenue by 15% without spending an extra dollar on acquisition.
For a firm doing $500K a month, that’s $75K in incremental revenue. From people who already bought from you.
And here’s the part that makes it even more compelling.
Repeat buyers tend to buy larger challenges. They’ve been through the process. They know the rules. They’re more confident. They trade up.
A trader who bought a $50K evaluation the first time will often buy a $100K or $200K evaluation the second time. Your average order value goes up. Your LTV goes up. Your marketing efficiency goes up.
All because you didn’t let them disappear after a failed challenge.
Why Traders Buy Again (The Psychology)
To build a retention system, you need to understand why a trader comes back. It’s not random. It’s driven by specific psychological patterns.
4 Psychological Drivers of Repeat Purchases
Sunk Cost Effect
The trader already invested money and time into the first challenge. Walking away means admitting that investment was wasted.
Coming back means the first purchase was “step one” of a journey, not a dead end.
Your messaging can frame it that way:
> “Your first challenge wasn’t a loss. It was a learning round. Now you know the rules. Now you know the platform. Round two is where it counts.”
This reframes failure as investment. And it works because it’s true. Most traders do perform better on their second attempt because they understand the evaluation structure.
The Redemption Arc
We covered this in our emotional selling post, but it’s worth repeating here because it’s the single strongest driver of repeat purchases.
A trader who failed doesn’t want to be someone who failed. They want to be someone who failed and came back and made it.
That’s a story they can tell themselves. That’s an identity they can aspire to. Your job is to hand them that narrative.
> “Most funded traders didn’t pass on their first try. They passed because they tried again.”
System Refinement
Some traders are methodical. They treat the first challenge as a test run. They want to see how the platform works, how the rules feel in practice, and where their strategy needs adjustment.
These traders are going to buy again regardless. But they’ll buy again faster if you make it easy and if you acknowledge their approach.
> “You’ve seen how our evaluation works. Your strategy is solid. Time to execute it for real.”
Social Proof from Peers
When a trader sees other people in their community getting funded — especially people who also failed first — the competitive drive kicks in.
“If they can do it, I can do it.”
This is why payout showcases, leaderboards, and community-driven content matter for retention, not just acquisition. They remind previous buyers that the destination is real and other people like them are reaching it.
The Five Flows That Drive Repeat Purchases
Retention isn’t one email. It’s a system of flows that catch traders at different stages and bring them back at the right moment.
The 5 Retention Flows
Flow 1: Post-Failure Re-Engagement
This is the most important flow and the one most firms either don’t have or get completely wrong.
Timing: Trigger immediately after a challenge ends in failure.
The Sequence:
Email 1 (Day 0): Acknowledgment. Not a sales pitch. Not a discount code. “Your evaluation ended. Here’s what happened. Here’s what your data shows.” If you have analytics on their trading behavior, share it. Show them their average win rate, their drawdown pattern, their best trading days. Make this email useful, not promotional.
Email 2 (Day 2): Education. Share a resource that addresses the most common reason traders fail. If most failures come from drawdown violations, send a piece about risk management. If most come from overtrading, send a piece about discipline. The goal is to help them believe the next attempt can be different.
Email 3 (Day 5): Social proof. Share a story of a trader who failed and came back and got funded. Make it specific. Name (with permission), account size, timeline. Real stories convert better than generic testimonials.
Email 4 (Day 7): The offer. Now you can sell. “Ready for round two? Here’s a [specific incentive] to get back in.” This could be a discount, a free reset, a challenge upgrade, or a bonus add-on. The key is that it feels earned after the value you provided in emails 1-3. Not random.
Email 5 (Day 14): Last chance urgency. “Your incentive expires in 48 hours.” Soft close. If they don’t convert here, move them to the longer-term win-back flow.
Flow 2: Post-Purchase Reinforcement
This flow fires after every purchase, not just after failure. Its job is to reduce buyer’s remorse, build excitement, and pre-sell the next purchase.
Timing: Starts immediately after purchase.
Email 1 (Day 0): “Welcome to your evaluation.” Confirm the purchase, set expectations, share a quick-start guide.
Email 2 (Day 1): “How to give yourself the best chance of passing.” Educational content. Rules breakdown. Common mistakes.
Email 3 (Day 3): Community invitation. Discord, Telegram, whatever your community platform is. The goal is to embed the trader in your ecosystem so they don’t just buy from you. They belong to you.
Email 4 (Midway through evaluation): Check-in. “You’re halfway through. Here’s how you’re tracking.” If you can pull data, make this personalized.
This flow matters because a trader who feels supported and connected is far more likely to purchase again, whether they pass or fail. You’re not just selling a product. You’re building a relationship.
Flow 3: Win-Back
For traders who purchased 60-90+ days ago and haven’t come back.
This is your long-tail retention play. These traders have gone cold, but they haven’t forgotten you. They just need a reason to come back.
Email 1: “It’s been a while.” Acknowledge the gap. Don’t be weird about it. “You haven’t traded with us in a few months. The market’s still here. So are we.”
Email 2: Product update. “Here’s what’s changed since you were last here.” New features, new challenge types, new payout records, new rules. Give them a reason to reconsider.
Email 3: “Welcome back” offer that makes sense. Not a generic 10% off. Something that acknowledges they’re a returning customer.
Flow 4: Loyalty and Gamification
This isn’t a single email sequence. It’s a system layer.
Traders are gamers at heart. They respond to points, tiers, achievements, and status.
Consider building a loyalty structure where repeat purchases unlock benefits. After your second challenge, you get a free reset on your next one. After your third, you get a reduced profit split. After your fifth, you get priority support or early access to new products.
This doesn’t have to be complex. Even a simple “Returning Trader” badge or a visible purchase count on their dashboard creates a sense of progression. And progression is what keeps gamers playing.
Flow 5: Promotional Sequences
When you run a promotion, don’t blast your entire list with the same email.
Segment.
Previous buyers who haven’t purchased in 30-60 days get a different message than brand-new subscribers. “You know our challenges. You know the rules. This is the best price we’ve offered since you last bought.”
That’s more compelling than a generic “SALE! 50% OFF!” because it speaks to their specific history with your brand.
Segment further. Traders who failed get a redemption-framed promo. Traders who passed get an upgrade-framed promo. Traders who haven’t bought in 90+ days get a win-back framed promo.
Same sale. Different messages. Dramatically different conversion rates.
The Metric That Changes Everything
Once you start tracking repeat purchase rate, everything shifts.
Your acquisition strategy changes because you know the true LTV of a buyer, not just the first purchase value.
Your offer strategy changes because you start thinking about the second sale before the first one closes.
And your email strategy finally has a job that goes beyond “send a discount.”
Most prop firms are sitting on a goldmine of previous buyers and doing absolutely nothing with them. The firms that build real retention systems will scale faster, spend more efficiently, and compound revenue in ways that acquisition-only firms never will.
---
At FiFuel, we don’t just build acquisition campaigns. We build the full growth system, including the retention engine that turns one-time buyers into repeat customers. Let’s talk about your repeat purchase rate.
Related Posts
- How to Emotionally Sell to a Trader — The psychology behind why traders buy (and how to trigger it)
- Why Most Prop Firms Suck at Marketing — The 6 deadly sins killing your growth
- How to Test Ad Creative at Your Prop Firm — The full framework for systematic creative testing
- Stop Crutching on Discounts — Why discounts are killing your brand and what to do instead
